Skip to Main Content

Controversial Monuments

This libguide serves to provide an introduction to the topic of the removal of historical monuments including its historical context, public perception and resources available through UMD and other outside organizations.

International Case Studies

The removal of historical statues is not only an American debate but also a global one. The cases presented in this section are representative of these countries' own history, their complications, and the ways in which they are trying to rectify them. This section is by no means intended to be comprehensive of the entire scope of monuments being challenged across the world but rather an insight into just a few perspectives outside of the American context.

(Image Description: Defacement of statue of Leopold II, Belgium.)

Getty Images

Various Former Soviet Republics

Once Soviet-controlled countries including Poland, Ukraine, Estonia and Latvia are engaged in a movement to remove Soviet Monuments. While some recent cases have been precipitated due to the Russian attack on Ukraine, such as the case of the dismantling of the Arch of Freedom of the Ukrainian People, others have been based on years-long tensions with the history of communism and the Soviet Party. For many of those once in Soviet-controlled countries, the monuments represent a dark time and years of oppression. 

  • List of monuments and memorials removed following the Russian invasion of Ukraine
    • Wikipedia page listing the monuments removed across the Slavic nations as of February 2022.
  • Museum of Communism
    • This museum is dedicated to documenting and educating visitors about the history of communism, including the Soviet Union's impact on Eastern European nations, particularly in Communist-era Czechoslovakia.
  • Museum of Occupations
    • This museum focuses on the occupations of Estonia, first by the Soviet Union and then by Nazi Germany, and later by the Soviet Union again. It provides insights into the experiences of the Estonian people during these periods.
  • The Museum of Genocides / Museum of Occupations and Freedom Fights
    • This museum located in a decommissioned KGB prison, documents the history of repression and resistance during the Soviet occupation of Lithuania.
  • Ukrainian Institute of National Memory
    • This institution is dedicated to preserving and promoting the memory of the victims of totalitarian regimes in Ukraine, including the Soviet era.
  • Institute of National Remembrance
    • An organization focused on documenting crimes committed against the Polish Nation, from the October Revolution, throughout the Second World War and the communist period, to the dissolution of the Soviet Union.

United Kingdom

In the United Kingdom, actions have been taken to remove monuments that represent the problematic figures in its history, particularly those involved with colonialism and the slave trade. On June 7, 2020,  a statue of Edward Colson was graffitied and pushed into the Bristol Habour, in Bristol, England. Colton was a notorious slave trader and was a senior executive of the Royal African Company, considered the largest in England, from 1689-1690. The monument's toppling was only part of a larger conversation on the city confronting its history of racism. The statue was later removed from the water and was on display at the Bristol Museum from June 2021 to January 2022, where it is now held in collections.

  • Actions against memorials in Great Britain during the George Floyd protests
    • Wikipedia page listing the monuments removed in the UK throughout 2020.
  • Black Cultural Archives
    • This London-Based organization focuses on collecting, preserving, and celebrating the histories of people of African and Caribbean descent in the UK. Their project Decolonizing the Archive "exists to ensure that #blackarchives are defined and disseminated by people of African heritage."
  • Bristol Radical History Group
    • This group conducts research and hosts events that focus on the hidden and often suppressed histories of Bristol, including its role in the transatlantic slave trade.
  • Decolonising SOAS
    • This project at the University of South London focuses its efforts on decolonizing higher education institutions and challenging the racist history and structures in the UK.
  • Historic England
    • The Immortalised Campaign held by the public agency, Historic England, in 2018, asked those across the UK to examine monuments and consider questions such as who is being memorialized and why? This exhibit included a look into England's unknown and forgotten memorials.
  • International Slavery Museum
    • This museum based in Liverpool, England, focuses on the history of slavery in the UK and its lasting effect in contemporary society.
  • The Runnymede Trust
    • This is an independent-run think tank used to research racial inequality in the UK's past and present

Belgium

Belgium has been removing statues representing its involvement in colonialism and the slave trade. Statues of the Belgian King, Leopold II, have been under particular scrutiny. The regent is known for his brutal legacy in the Congo which led to the brutalization of Congolese people who were forced to endure grueling forced labor for the production of rubber and ivory. Leopold's private military force known as the Force Publique were agents of mutilations, murders, and extreme forms of torture during this time. While the exact number is not known, it is estimated that at least 10 million people died during the Congo Free State from 1885 to 1908. In 2020, a group known as Let's Repair History (Reparons l'Histoire) started a change.org petition to remove all statues of the late king in the city of Brussels, which ran from June 1 to June 30, ending on the 60th anniversary of Congo's independence. In total, the campaign received 84,414 signatures.

  • CegeSoma
    • This is a federal research center that focuses on the history of Belgium in the 20th century, including its role in colonialism and the subsequent impacts. 
  • Hand In Hand Against Racism
    • This is a Belgian movement to fight against structural racism within Belgian and Flemish society. One of their recent campaigns, Decolonize Heritage, seeks to decentralize Western culture as the forefather of modernity and examine the ways in which Eurocentric ideals infiltrate the world.
  • Kif Kif
    • This is a Belgian organization that aims to promote equality and fight racism through various initiatives including cultural projects, campaigns, and educational programs.
  • Royal Museum for Central Africa
    • This museum is one of the most prominent institutions that addresses Belgium's colonial history in Africa. The museum underwent significant renovation and rebranding in recent years to provide a more critical and inclusive perspective on colonialism and its impact. It explores the history, culture, and legacy of Belgian colonial rule in Central Africa.

South Africa

In South Africa, citizens have been critical of apartheid-era statues which represent a painful and divisive period of the country's history. In particular, statues depicting the former prime minister of the Cape Colony, Cecil John Rhodes, have been under contention. Rhodes was a prominent proponent of British colonialism in Africa and was a staunch supporter of racial segregation, believing the white race to be superior. In March 9 2015, a campaign known as The Rhodes Must Fall Campaign was launched by university students attending the University of Cape Town, calling for the removal of a statue dedicated to Rhodes, citing its symbolism in racism and apartheid. The university agreed to remove the statue by a council vote on April 9, 2015, and would be removed the following day. 

  • Apartheid Museum
    • This museum, located in Johannesburg, focuses on educating visitors on the history of Apartheid and its role in South African society. 
  • Desmond & Leah Tutu Legacy Foundation
    • This foundation, dedicated to Archbishop Desmond Tutu and his wife, focuses on advocacy work in social justice and human rights in social justice. 
  • Institute for Justice and Reconciliation (IJR)
    • This organization focuses on the history of apartheid and post-apartheid issues. They are dedicated to research, policy development, and promoting social justice and reconciliation within South Africa as well as throughout all of Africa.
    Nelson Mandela Foundation
    • This foundation, founded by the former president of South Africa, Nelson Mandela, focuses on educational programming and generating dialogue about human rights in a post-apartheid society. The foundation also focuses on memorializing Mandela's memory with its extensive archives on his life and career. 
  • South Africa History Online (SAHO)
    • This online database is a comprehensive overview for learning about South African history, including apartheid. Topics include such things as politics, places, arts and culture, and important figures.